Sunday, September 16, 2007

Can consumers be confused into buying?

Engraving The Confusion of Tongues by Gustave Doré (1865)Can consumers be confused into buying? Yes -- and more easily than you think

An important article from the October issue of the Journal of Consumer Research examines the effectiveness of a new confusion-based sales technique called “disrupt-then-reframe.”
The researchers found that by presenting a confusing sales pitch to consumers and then restating the pitch in a more familiar way, they were able to increase sales of a candy bar in a supermarket, increase students’ willingness to pay to join a student interest group, and increase students’ acceptance of a tuition increase.

“Although encounters between commercial sales representatives and consumers are one of the more common types of interpersonal interactions found in everyday life, relatively little research has been conducted on interpersonal influence attempts applied to commercial settings,” write Frank R. Kardes (University of Cincinnati), Bob M. Fennis (University of Twente, the Netherlands), Edward R. Hirt, Zakary L. Tormala, and Brian Bullington (all of the University of Indiana).

Consumers in the study were confused with an unusual monetary request (e.g., 100 cents for a candy bar, 300 cents to join a student interest group, or 7500 cents for a tuition increase). However, the researchers found that a confusing sales pitch alone – such as one utilizing technical jargon, confusing terminology, or large and confusing product assortments – does not lead to greater consumer interest. Rather, it increases the “need for cognitive closure”; consumers will grasp for easy-to-process or unambiguous information that has direct and obvious implications for judgment and behavior.

Furthermore, the researchers found that this need for cognitive closure will cause particularly susceptible consumers to “freeze” their judgments, that is, hold them with a high degree of confidence and refrain from considering additional evidence that could potentially threaten closure.

“Most of the prior research that has been conducted on sales pitches has focused on alpha strategies, or strategies for increasing persuasion,” the researchers explain. “Our research suggests that more research should focus on omega strategies, or strategies for reducing resistance to persuasion.” ###

Frank R. Kardes, Bob M. Fennis, Edward R. Hirt, Zakary L. Tormala, and Brian Bullington, “The Role of the Need for Cognitive Closure in the Effectiveness of the Disrupt-the-Reframe Influence Technique.” Journal of Consumer Research: October 2007.

Contact: Suzanne Wu 209-608-2038 University of Chicago Press Journals

Technorati Tags: and or and or Presidential Podcast 09/15/07 and Halloween Night Pumpkin and Witch and Yale scientists use nanotechnology to fight E. coli

Linkfest Haven, the Blogger's OasisTrackposted to Outside the Beltway, Perri Nelson's Website, Blog at,
Rosemary's Thoughts, Mark My Words, DeMediacratic Nation, Right Truth, Big Dog's Weblog, DragonLady's World, Nuke's News & Views, Webloggin, Leaning Straight Up, The Amboy Times, Conservative Cat, Adeline and Hazel, Pursuing Holiness, Conservative Thoughts, Rosemary\'s Thoughts, third world county, Blue Star Chronicles, Pirate's Cove, Wake Up America, The Pink Flamingo, CORSARI D'ITALIA, High Desert Wanderer, Gone Hollywood, and The Yankee Sailor, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

Trackback URL:

27 Trackbacks to this Post:

NY Times To Educate Kids on Good Ol’ ‘Pre-Reagan’ Days of Sex and Drugs Excerpt: I found little coincidence in the fact that yesterday’s New York Times Learning Network word of the day was “belie“. Especially considering that this weeks lesson plan for teachers (grades 3-12) is a romantic walk down the path of the... Weblog: Webloggin Tracked: 09.18.07 - 5:34 am

Iranian Peaceful Nukes - Almost there on Agreeme Excerpt: "We do not take these statements seriously. Comments to the media are different from real statements" – Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in ... Weblog: DeMediacratic Nation Tracked: 09.18.07 - 5:45 am

HillaryCare II: HillaryCare I Was Not Sneaky Enou Excerpt: An NRO Symposium on HillaryCare the Second, "Dr Hillary Will See ... Weblog: DeMediacratic Nation Tracked: 09.18.07 - 6:24 am

Sanctions Against Iran Limited: Germany and Iran B Excerpt: If you're interested in continued business and care very little for or even recognize the threat from the Islamic Republic of Iran, be sure to visit:Weblog: DeMediacratic Nation Tracked: 09.18.07 - 8:42 am

No Campaign Solution for Health Care Says: Besides the title, the first sentence draws attention and interest in this AP report presented below. One can probably find plenty of examples of issues Weblog: Blog at 09.18.07 at 9:40 am

Iraq and Iran; Not Separate Issues, Pieces of the Excerpt: From the point of view of most Democrats in Washington Weblog: DeMediacratic Nation Tracked: 09.18.07 - 10:26 am

Right Voices OPEN TRACKBACK: “Allah is our goal; the Messenger is our model; the Quran is our constitution; jihad is our means; and martyrdom in the way of Allah is our aspiration.”… H/T to Bryan for the link to the Muslim Brotherhood’s long term goals in the US, which include replacing the Constitution with sharia law. Amid the mountain of evidence released in the Holy Land Foundation terrorism financing trial, the most provocat… 09.18.07 11:13 am

How did Denver cheat? Ask the Ref's Excerpt: They put the 3 points on the scoreboard, and the game was won. It was over. People started on their way home. But wait! What is this? They’re taking the points off the board! What is happening? The Raiders have to try again. Why? What is the penalty?... Weblog: Rosemary's Thoughts Tracked: 09.18.07 - 12:13 pm

Colorado Man's POW/MIA Flag Design Keeps Movement Flying Excerpt: Colorado Springs Gazette: One day this week is set aside to mark military sacrifices and open wounds on the national psyche that have lingered for more than four decades. And even the military is marking it in the quietest way, Weblog: Diary of the Mad Pigeon Tracked: 09.18.07 - 3:15 pm

Conservative Cat Says: Student Electrified During Kerry Speech Earlier today, Vietnam war veteran and former presidential candidate John Kerry was doing a Q & A session at the University of Florida, and a student was attempting to condense every known liberal conspiracy theory into three questions for the 09.18.07 at 3:24 pm

Brutality with a taser? Excerpt: At the University of Florida campus during a John Kerry speech, Andrew Meyer, a journalism student, tried to ask the Senator several questions. Judging from some of the videos and eyewitness reports, the kid ... Weblog: Mark My Words Tracked: 09.18.07 - 4:50 pm

Freedom will always Offend someone Excerpt: In our primitive past, and I am only going back a mere few centuries, people did not tolerate other people's culture or beliefs. It was enough that you were different by only a scintilla of coloring or hairstyle or language or smell. Weblog: planck's constant Tracked: 09.18.07 - 5:21 pm

The Amboy Times Says: Chavez Tightens the Noose
This time he clamps down on private schools.President Hugo Chavez threatened on Monday to take over any private schools refusing to submit to the oversight of his socialist government, a move some Venezuelans fear will impose leftist ideology in the ... 09.18.07 at 5:37 pm

Tropical Storm Ivo forms in the eastern Pacific Excerpt: Tropical Storm Ivo just developed off the coast of Mexico this evening and currently has 45 MPH winds. The projections are for Ivo to remain as a storm and may threaten the southern tip of Baja California by early next week. Weblog: Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker Tracked: 09.18.07 - 7:29 pm

Pirate's Cove Says: Murtha Pulls A Standard Lib Blame Someone Else And guess who he is going to blame if the Democrats force an early withdrawl from Iraq for any ensuing bloodbath? If pulling U.S. troops out of Iraq results in "a bloodbath," the guilt will rest with the Iraqi people and not with the U.S. Co… 09.18.07 at 7:30 pm

Tropical Storm Ivo forms in the eastern PacificHurricane Dean Blog » Blog Archive Says: Tropical Storm Ivo just developed off the coast of Mexico this evening and currently has 45 MPH winds. The projections are for Ivo to remain as a storm and may threaten the southern tip of Baja California by early next week. 09.18.07 at 7:45 pm

Adam's Blog Says: Constitution in the Balance
On Tonight’s Truth and Hope Report…declining respect for our constitution leads to talk of DC Congressional Representation. Also how one company turned $1.3 million into $100 million by giving Jack Murtha and Friends. And, is Hillarycare th ... 09.18.07 at 8:03 pm

Possible storm development Excerpt: Once this system drifts into the Gulf of Mexico, it is likely to develop into a cyclone - either a tropical storm or potentially even a hurricane. Weblog: Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker Tracked: 09.18.07 - 8:05 pm

Possible storm developmentHurricane Dean Blog » Blog Archive Says: Once this system drifts into the Gulf of Mexico, it is likely to develop into a cyclone - either a tropical storm or potentially even a hurricane. 09.18.07 at 8:43 pm

Arab countries are silent on Syrian nukes taken out by Israel Excerpt: So far as I know, not one word from Arab countries concerning the recent incursion of Israelis into Syrian air space and the 'take out' of suspected nuclear materials. In fact everybody is quiet. Israeli intelligence is not confirming or Weblog: Right Truth Tracked: 09.18.07 - 8:44 pm

Right Voices Says: Linkfest:WaPa Calls Thompson A Liar For Stating That U.S. Has Shed More Blood Than Any Other Nation To Bring Liberty Here is what Fred said:“You know, you look back over our history, and it doesn’t take you long to realize that our people have shed more blood for other people’s liberty than any other combination of nations in the history of the wor… Tracked: 09.19.07 7:30 am

Pirate’s Cove » >>Americans Never Quit » Aaar! Talki Like A Pirate Day, Mateys! Says: Yes, it be that time yet again, ye scurvy rats! International Talk Like a Pirate Day! How do ye plan to celebrate this day, Mates? Tracked:09.19.07 at 9:40 am

I finally did it. I bought a site! Excerpt: I would to thank everyone here who has been just as kind as anyone could hope for in any era. I remember when I asked which of the two sites you liked better. Some of you liked both, some, like me, could not make up their mind. Trust me, I know h ...... Weblog: Rosemary's Thoughts Tracked: 09.19.07 - 11:06 pm

The World According To Carl Says Beware The Cell Phone Battery Scam, I’ve been using an LG cell phone for a couple of years now. Maybe longer, I’m not sure. But the battery that came with it was definitely on its last legs 09.19.07 at 11:37 am

The World According To Carl Says: Strange Video: Familjen - “Det Snurrar I Min Skalle” This video is highly unusual. The footage comes from unknown (at least to me) film footage from the 1960’s (possibly) of a charismatic healing service most likely from somewhere in Europe. It’s spliced together in such a way to make it appear that … 09.19.07 at 11:38 am

Pirate's Cove Says: WTW: Fact Checking Fred At The Wash. Post Afternoon, y’all. Jebediah Murphy here, bringin’ you the truth. Thought I would let Teach get some milage out of Talk Like a Pirate Day. Now, it seems as if them thar critters at the Washington Post are starting a new feature ca… 09.19.07 at 3:30 pm

The World According To Carl Says: Sometimes the idiocy of people amazes me. Earlier this evening was a prime example. I am driving home from work on a 4-lane road. A rather well-worn (some would call it “beat up”) work pickup truck passes me in the left lane. 09.20.07 at 12:20 am

No comments:

Post a Comment